“Tax Expenditures”: Not Taxing Is Allegedly Spending

open quote Runaway government spending is among the most important economic problems of our time. It is absolutely urgent that it be brought under control and progressively reduced until it is sufficient to provide for no more than the essential government functions of defense and justice. Only then will the citizens have the greatest possible individual freedom to decide how their earnings are spent and the greatest possible motivation to increase their earnings and improve their standard of living.

As recognition of the importance of bringing government spending under control has grown, the enemies of individual freedom have seized upon a tactic which they hope will avoid the necessity of reducing government spending, and, will allow them to go on increasing it, under a fraudulently created appearance of reduction. The tactic is described as “tax expenditure.”

More precisely, a tax expenditure is a fictional, non-existent tax accompanied by an equivalent fictional, non-existent expenditure. Although the government does not actually collect the tax, the fact that it has the power to do so is used as the basis for pretending that it does collect the tax and that it uses the proceeds to make an expenditure that goes to those from whom it has chosen not to collect the tax. In this way, the taxes that are not collected are treated as though they were collected and then used as a subsidy paid to those from whom they were not collected. In effect, the government’s not taking is alleged to be giving. Its not taxing is alleged to be spending.

Examples of tax expenditures recently provided by The New York Times are the taxation of capital gains and dividends at lower rates than ordinary income; allowance for deductions from taxable income of the payment of interest on home mortgages, the payment of property taxes, state and local income taxes, charitable contributions; and the absence of taxation on employees for health insurance and pension benefits paid for by employers on their behalf. All in all, according to The Times, “Tax expenditures cost the federal government more than $1 trillion a year in lost revenue.”

When one recalls that in World War II, there was a 90-percent bracket in the federal income tax, and that the government has it in its power to impose such a tax rate on everyone but presently chooses not to do so, then it becomes clear that by the logic of the concept, the cost of tax expenditures to the federal government is not just $1 trillion, but many, many trillions. It is, in fact, everyone’s entire income and wealth.

The philosophical principle underlying the concept of tax expenditure is that we are all serfs or slaves in the power of our Lord and Master the Almighty Government. It owns us and all of our income and wealth. All that we earn and possess, we do so by virtue of its largess, by virtue of its giving to us what we may have believed was ours to begin with. close quote (Read more)

One comment

  1. “The philosophical principle underlying the concept of
    tax expenditure is that we are all serfs or slaves in the
    power of our Lord and Master the Almighty Government.
    It owns us and all of our income and wealth. All that we
    earn and possess, we do so by virtue of its largess, by
    virtue of its giving to us what we may have believed
    was ours to begin with.” by George Reisman

    Gee, I made that analogy in the 1960’s. The liberals tout
    Marx as great thinker when all he did was replace
    feudalism’s king and court with his Marxism. Nothing
    new here.

    addendum:

    “There will not be an economic recovery
    given the economic policies of this
    country. A recovery is not unlikely, I
    would argue it is closer to impossible
    if not impossible. The reasons for this
    position are not complicated. In short,
    the nation has become an out-of-control
    welfare state that is rapidly destroying
    the incentives to work or create jobs.”

    http://www.economicnoise.com/2013/04/05/the-country-is-over/

    http://tartanmarine.blogspot.com/

    “The depositors in Cyprus believed they
    owned what was in their bank accounts.
    They found out otherwise. Bondholders
    of General Motors believed they were
    protected by bankruptcy laws when GM
    was bankrupted by the government. They
    found out otherwise. Do you own your
    pension plans and IRAs. Well you always
    believed you did except now there is talk
    about confiscating a portion or all of
    these funds.”

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

*