I don’t speak for all conservatives, but I speak for at least some of them:
We reject your observations. We reject your logic. We reject your conclusions. And most importantly, we reject your demands. We have no common ground to build on. We have no common vision to work toward. No amount of shaming and pearl-clutching outrage will change my mind – you’ve exhausted your credibility. If you want cooperation, show me what is in it for me, my family, and my extended family.
(For the record, I regard it as a bit of a tragedy that Universalism is dead. But you killed it. I spent a lot of time trying to preserve it, but your demands for parasitic relations, your lies, your violence, your hypocrisy has made it impossible. I don’t wish you any harm, only separation. I cannot help you. My hope is that forcing you to live with the consequences of your parasitic ideology will change you, because I cannot.)